Friday, 13 June 2008

Why ley-lines annoy me

Ley lines result from a process of joining up monuments on the map that have no connection with each other, possibly based on the assumption that all medieval churches were built on top of ancient pagan sites (in reality, only a few were, such as Knowlton Henge and St Paul's Cathedral). Thus you get a rather arbitrary line drawn across the map joining monuments that were built hundreds, even thousands, of years apart.

They're linear. Surely energy moving in the landscape would move in swirly patterns around the contours of the hills and the geology? More like water. I don't think Chinese feng shui practitioners have detected any ley lines, though they're very good at finding energy movements in the landscape. There are also electrical currents in the Earth's crust and mantle, which interact in a complex way; these are known as telluric currents. Ley lines are also not the same as song-lines, which are actually known to Indigenous Australians as the 'Footprints of the Ancestors' or the 'Way of the Law'.

When Alfred Watkins talked about leys, he was talking about prehistoric trackways. The whole concept has been expanded to mean mythical energy lines across the landscape, such as the Mary and Michael Line (which is sometimes depicted as swirly, but does arbitrarily join up unconnected monuments).

Also, ley lines are becoming congested:
Ley lines in certain parts of Britain are becoming so congested with hippies, travellers and mildly frightening-looking people with coat hangers that the government has today announced a multi-million pound ten year ley line building programme.
I'm not saying that there isn't energy in the land (it feels to me as though there is); I'm just deeply skeptical about it moving along mysterious and arbitrary lines.

Of course, if you want to argue for ley-lines as a mythopoeic or metaphorical construct, that would be different. But I very much doubt that they objectively exist, especially as there are no ethnographic parallels and little or no evidence for them in indigenous British folklore.

1 comment:

Unknown said...

My home town of Crieff in Perthshire has about 70 alignments to the streets of the town, including the outlying roads which have been designed in a zig-zag pattern, aligned with standing stones and circles, burial grounds, etc. Even some 12 miles of irrigation ditches built by the monks are in a zig-zag pattern of alignments. The town is also built in a six pointed star shape - the main roads are in the shape of a right-angled triangle with energies aligned with distant volcanic plugs. There are several large boulders which are also the fulcrums in the design. The town is on the Highland Boundary Fault which standing stones can use to pick up the energy from geological fissures and dykes. My website is - click on yellow button at top right "Lyn, Sacred Strathearn" My recent video shows a sensible approach to ley lines, how they get supplied with energy and even how to amplify that energy.